District of Columbia officials have already forced one of the world’s largest entertainment companies to pay millions for deceptive ticket pricing. Now, four major online ticket resellers are asking a federal judge to block the District from limiting how much they can charge concertgoers, setting up another confrontation over an industry that has turned a night of live music into an increasingly expensive privilege.

SeatGeek, Vivid Seats, Gametime, and TickPick, along with the Ticket Policy Forum, are challenging the District’s new RESALE Act, which restricts ticket markups and marketplace fees. District attorneys filed a blistering 60-page response this week, accusing the companies of seeking court protection after failing to defeat the legislation before the D.C. Council.

“Striking out with the democratic process, Plaintiffs dressed their policy objections up in constitutional garb and turned to this Court for a judicial veto,” attorneys for the District wrote.

The confrontation follows an April agreement under which Live Nation, Ticketmaster’s parent company, must pay $9.9 million to Washington after Attorney General Brian Schwalb’s office investigated years of hidden fees, misleading prices and sales tactics that pressured customers. Up to $8.9 million was set aside for consumer refunds.

“For at least a decade, Live Nation and Ticketmaster boosted profits by charging predatory, hidden fees,” Schwalb said when announcing the settlement, accusing the companies of exploiting District residents and pricing others out of entertainment altogether.

The Live Nation settlement concerns primary ticketing practices, while the new lawsuit targets restrictions on secondary ticket sales. Both cases involve the enormous sums collected between an artist’s performance and a fan’s seat.

Under the RESALE Act, most concert and theater tickets cannot be resold for more than 10% above their original total purchase price. Online marketplaces may charge an additional service fee of up to 10% of the original amount and must disclose the ticket’s original cost. Sporting events and movie screenings are excluded.

The Council unanimously approved the measure on July 14. Mayor Muriel Bowser signed it on Aug. 10, and its requirements take effect on Jan. 1.

The resellers contend that D.C. cannot regulate internet transactions between residents outside the District. They also argue that original ticket prices are sometimes unavailable, making compliance difficult or impossible.

Brian Berry, executive director of the Ticket Policy Forum, warned that the law would “drive ticket sales into the shadows,” leaving consumers vulnerable to scams and fraud.

D.C. attorneys rejected the companies’ constitutional arguments, maintaining that tickets for Washington performances remain tied to the city regardless of where buyers and sellers live.

Councilmember Charles Allen (D-Ward 6), who sponsored the legislation, accused resale companies of using technology to buy tickets and resell them at inflated prices.

A federal judge is considering whether to block enforcement before January. The companies have requested a ruling by Dec. 10.

Allen offered little sympathy for their predicament.

“It’s not surprising to see them try for an encore to preserve these enormous profits and the status quo,” he stated.

Stacy M. Brown is a senior writer for The Washington Informer and the senior national correspondent for the Black Press of America. Stacy has more than 25 years of journalism experience and has authored...

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *