Much to the chagrin of some media critics, scholars and television fans, reality television is here to stay. Colloquially referred to as “ratchet TV,” reality television is loved and loathed often by the same fan base who like or detest the genre for the same reasons.
Some of the reality shows, particularly those with all-women and all-Black casts, have become synonymous with promoting the worst of women’s behavior with constant bickering, physical fighting, back-stabbing, pettiness, anger and mean-spiritedness put on full display.
Many believe the shows highlight the most stereotypical behavior of women in general and Black women in particular. Others enjoy the genre as an escape from the reality of their everyday lives and appreciate the entrepreneurial endeavors of the women on the shows, sometimes resulting in spinoffs like “Vanderpump Rules” and retail businesses owned by members of the casts of “RHOA,” “RHONY,” “RHOP” and “Love and Hip-Hop Atlanta.”
Whether network or cable television programs, reality television shows garner some of the highest ratings in broadcast and cable television.
Season 12 of “The Real Housewives of Atlanta” (RHOA) returned to television Sunday, Nov. 3 and “Real Housewives of Beverly Hills” made history by adding actress Garcelle Beauvais to the cast, making the former model the first Black woman on that particular franchise.
“Married to Medicine’s” programming day has been changed multiple times, yet and still their fans continue to find them and bring new fans with them along the way.
There’s an old adage that says you should never discuss politics or religion in polite company. Perhaps another category should be added: Reality television.
If you want to hear a heated debate, then bring up reality television in any number of settings and a range of responses and emotions will surface. Some live for the genre, while others despise the television category which is broad enough to include “Cops,” “The Bachelor,” “The Masked Singer,” “Dog The Bounty Hunter,” “90 Day Fiancé,” “Say Yes to the Dress,” “House Hunters,” “RHOA,” “Chopped” and a host of other reality shows.
Reality shows continuously rank high on ratings lists; reality shows featuring women casts and all-Black casts continuously rank high on cable ratings lists.
Not only are the shows popular on television, they spawn other streams of revenue for reality show stars. Cookbooks, restaurants, clothing stores, fitness videos, weight-loss products, earbuds and the like are being hawked by cast members of these shows.
“Real Housewives of New York’s” Bethenny Frankel built a multi-million-dollar empire with her Skinnygirl lifestyle brand. “RHOP” stars Gizelle Bryant and Karen Huger launched a make-up line and fragrance over the last three seasons. While “RHOA’s” Kandi Burress, who was already successful in music prior to being cast on “RHOA,” has morphed into a successful entrepreneur in online retail and restaurants.
“RHOA’s” NeNe Leakes has jettisoned to mainstream popularity, having starred on two network television series, other reality shows, performed on Broadway and is currently pursuing a career in stand-up comedy, among other businesses.
Model-turned-“RHOA” reality star Cynthia Bailey opened a modeling company and lunched a sunglass line. Cardi B launched herself musically into the stratosphere from her journey on “Love and Hip-Hop New York” to the 2017 cover of Rolling Stone magazine, relegating rock legend Fats Domino to a corner mention, en route to becoming rap music royalty.
It’s not just the women on these shows who are winning financially, but also the men. “The Apprentice’s” Bill Rancic sold his cigar company for millions to Synergy Brands, remained on the board of directors and continues to broker million-dollar deals.
Recently, “Love and Hip-Hop Hollywood’s” Ray J closed a $31 million deal securing the launch of his new electronics transportation brand Raycon.
Reality stars like K. Michelle, Huger (“RHOP”), Leakes, Shooter Gates (“LHHA”) also use their platforms to highlight important issues like domestic violence, rape and gun control. While reality television shows featuring primarily all-women casts are problematic, it is difficult to dismiss them and the genre itself with their consistent ratings, successful brands and businesses.
In fact, reality television shows became so popular with women audiences in the early 2000s that they displaced legendary soap operas like “All My Children” and “One Life to Live,” both of which had been on air for more than 40 years each at the time of cancellation (2011).
Reality television mimicked the narrative and stylistic elements of soap operas, but with far less production costs. For example, even though “90 Day Fiancé” is a popular reality show on TLC, reportedly, each couple gets $1,000 to $1,500 per episode, with some cast members starting GoFundMe pages to ask for help with bills.
“The Bachelorette” (ABC) earns $250,000 per season, while some “Teen Mom” (MTV) cast members like Catelyn Lowell earn $500,000 per season. As for the “Real Housewives” franchise (Bravo), the salary per season started off at $7,250 for the entirety of season 1 of “Real Housewives of New York.”
New reports claim Bethany Frankel made upwards of $1.5 million per season for her last turn on “RHON,” while Lisa Vanderpump (“The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills”) and Nene Leakes (“RHOA”) make up to $2.7 million per season. It is estimated that Kim Kardashian rakes in $7 million per season for “Keeping Up the Kardashians.”
While it is easy to assume that reality stars are making that kind of money, the vast majority are not, particularly on women cast shows whose reruns dominate daytime television programming and new episodes strike ratings gold for prime-time audiences.
Most reality shows of this type – women cast housewives shows – are filmed with three to five crew members on location, unlike soap operas which were historically filmed on set, with scores of crew members and star salaries that were in the millions of dollars.
The lower production costs of reality shows including crew and star salaries coupled with the rise of social media giants Facebook and Twitter brought the reign of daytime soap operas to a screeching halt.
While many want to get rid of what some call “Trash TV,” reality television is here to stay, if for no other reason than the high return on investment in the form of advertising and viewership relative to the low cost of production and distribution.
Reality show executive producers Andy Cohen, Mona Scott Young and Carlos King understand the business model and know it is good business to produce problematic reality shows. Despite the outcry on social media about the danger of reality television, the popularity of reality shows with audiences challenges the presumption that ratchet television is bad for the culture.
Mark Cunningham, professor of Black Popular Culture at Austin Community College, thinks the critique is wrapped in respectability politics.
“What we see on these shows falls under everything we discuss in other contexts as stereotyping: self- absorption, hypersexuality, overindulgence, superficiality, hyper-masculinity and so forth,” he offers. “I don’t buy into these critiques of the shows being worthless, although I do recognize that there is some truth to the critiques in terms of the stereotypical behaviors of those on the shows. People need to understand this is just one example of Black life. This is not all of Black life.”
The reality shows with Black women casts do represent the worst of what folks have to say about Black people, but they also fill the desire for Black people in general and Black women specifically to be seen on television.
“These shows emerged at a time when Black women were pretty nonexistent within mainstream media,” said Dr. Alfred L. Martin Jr., assistant professor of media studies in the departments of Communication Studies and African American Studies at the University of Iowa. “So, on one hand, they were feeding an un-satiated appetite for Black female representation. On the other hand, these representations emerge in a post-network environment where networks are seeking modes of differentiation in an ever more crowded television landscape.
“At the same time, these representations are complicated in the ways they mix the respectable and the ratchet. So, in a way, they break from ‘Saint’ Clair Huxtable, who did not have a ‘negative’ bone in her representational body. These Black female reality TV characters — and they are characters versus necessarily being their “real” selves — are far more complex,” Martin adds.
It is impossible to dismiss the large audiences in general and women of color they draw despite the chorus of naysayers who believe the stereotypes bring more harm than good by playing into the “angry woman” stereotype among others.
Reality show viewer Miranda Solomon has diverse reasons for watching the shows.
“Specifically, I watch ‘Love and Listings’ because I sell real estate and am interested in seeing a show that is entirely focused on people of color doing what I do for a living. I also watch ‘Basketball Wives,’ ‘Love and Hip Hop’ (all cities), ‘Real Housewives of ATL’ and ‘Married to Medicine.’ I watch each of these shows as a mindless indulgence. Each of these shows provides just the right about of reality escape for me,” says Solomon, who also sees the reality in the show despite the cattiness.
“These shows draw large audiences because some showcase professional Black women and the triumphs and struggles we all experience daily. They highlight the iconic ‘Black Girl Magic’ that makes the whole world interested in what we are doing. The cat fighting and mean girl behavior definitely add to the entertainment value. I also love the way Black family life is highlighted on both of these shows (“RHOA” and “Married to Medicine”).”
When asked about the negative images perpetuated by both shows and the criticism the show receives because of these images, Solomon offers, “If you’re only watching the cattiness and the fighting, then it is easy to have that opinion. I actually follow the story lines of the characters. I find the characters’ family lives intriguing and, in many cases, endearing. I wonder if the critique is the same for White reality shows like ‘The Bachelor’ and ‘The Bachelorette’?”
Dr. Martin speaks to Solomon’s concerns:
“At base, that sort of critique is rooted in a racialized and racist understanding of blackness. White folks get to consume all sorts of garbage and their consumption is often bound within ‘ironic’ stances toward the ‘bad object’ or general notions of kitsch and camp. When Black folks consume ‘bad objects’ it is understood as endemic of our lack of taste, class and education. Of course, that goes back to Stuart Hall’s conceptualization of the function of the stereotype: to fix, essentialize, reduce and naturalize blackness as inherently inferior and ‘othered.’”
Therein lies the rub. Why is it that in a reality genre that is teeming with shows ranging from tow truck operators to police officers to college kids sharing a house together to dance teams and the lives of little people, are so many bothered by the Black cast reality shows? It is possible to realize that much of what you are watching is problematic and find some sense of pleasure in the show despite the problematic images? Is Rachel Lindsay, the first Black Bachelorette, any worse than the 20 “Bachelorettes” that came before her?
Some television viewers like Donna White, who rarely watches Black cast reality television shows because of the problematic images of Black people, understands why people want to see these images and believes the cast members should have the opportunity to use their platform to develop and grow their businesses.
However, White, who jokingly refers to herself as a “beanbag culture critic” is still bothered by the representation of Black people on these shows.
“Reality shows often perpetuate and reinforce stereotypes about Black love, relationships, and how Black people act and what is important to us. Black folks are dynamic and multidimensional people, but that is rarely captured on most reality shows,” she says.
When asked what it take for her to watch more Black reality shows, White states, “I would have to see the formula change. I don’t want to see Black women always fighting each other. I don’t want to see Black men with problematic lives juggling multiple women.”
When asked what type of show she would like to see, White offers, “I’d like to see something with travel and adventure.”
“What I want to see won’t sell and won’t garner the large audiences,” she says, making a sobering observation of the realities of Black cast reality television shows.
Is there room for more diverse representations of blacks on reality television shows? More importantly, if the formula changed as White would prefer, will audiences watch these new types of reality shows with the same fervor as “ratchet” reality shows? Does it have to come down to the respectable and the ratchet or is there something in between?
Burton is the entertainment and culture editor for NNPA/Black Press USA.