Lawmakers Step in to Protect Elder-Guardianship Arrangement

The “American tragedy” of a competent and spry 94-year-old Annapolis woman may have resonated with lawmakers.

Betty Winstanley had been living in an assisted-care facility and desperately seeking a transfer to be closer to her family. But a guardian appointed by a judge claimed Winstanley wasn’t competent enough to make such a decision despite the thousands of dollars she doles out to pay for her stay.

That same court-appointed guardian also refused to allow Winstanley to communicate with her own children, even when she’s been rushed to the hospital for varying reasons.

Winstanley’s case was among the many brought to light by investigative journalist Diane Dimond, who recently was honored at the National Press Club in D.C. for her dogged pursuit of justice for Winstanley and others.

Now, lawmakers have stepped up.

Federal officials should soon be empowered to go into states to investigate — and prosecute — unscrupulous court-appointed guardians and conservators who prey on their elderly wards.

“This is a really big deal, in my book, and a long-overdue first step in curbing the obvious abuses of this mostly secret system,” Dimond said.

According to experts, there are at least 1.3 million Americans currently living under guardianship control. They have between $50 billion and $300 billion in assets, which are at risk for exploitation.

Both houses of Congress have now passed the Elder Abuse Prevention and Prosecution Act, which would strengthen the laws on elder abuse, neglect and exploitation on several fronts, including that by telemarketers, email scammers and the like.

But Congress has also now finally recognized the well-documented nationwide scandal wherein judges sidestep family members and appoint outside, for-profit guardians to handle the financial and personal affairs of aging Americans.

In the end, hard-earned estates are frequently plundered, and families are left grieving. Inheritances wind up paying the fees of total strangers, Dimond said.

Many appointed guardians are good Samaritans who truly help the elderly who have either no family members or family members who are not available to help them in their final years.

“These kind souls step in to handle all aspects of seniors’ lives, from medical matters to housing to finances to funeral arrangements,” she said.

However, after more than two years of investigation, Dimond discovered a veritable racket of uncaring and dishonest guardians, their staffs, and elder law lawyers who concentrate more on billable hours [paid for out of the wards’ estates] than on what is truly in the elders’ best interests.

“These scoundrels have the power to isolate loving family members who ask too many questions about their loved one’s situation or where the money is going,” Dimond said.
“Many relatives have told me they weren’t allowed to see their aged parents in the months — or even years — before they died.”

If President Donald Trump were to sign this newly passed bill into law, the Department of Justice would assign at least one assistant U.S. attorney to each federal judicial district to investigate reports of wrongdoing by guardians.

These assistant U.S. attorneys would be empowered to bring in specially trained FBI agents to help investigate the complaints. And the law would require the DOJ to set up an elder abuse resource group to facilitate information sharing among all federal prosecutors.

When a dodgy guardian tactic is uncovered in one state, prosecutors could share their findings so counterparts could be on the lookout in other states.

And within 60 days of the president’s signing the bill, Attorney General Jeff Sessions would designate a DOJ elder justice czar to oversee this new investigative process.

“It’s not the best bill ever, but it’s a start,” Rick Black, executive director of Americans Against Abusive Probate Guardianship, told Dimond.

The AAAPG and other family-centered watchdog groups are happy that Washington has now acknowledged there is a major problem with state guardianship systems that see judges routinely declaring absent citizens as “incapacitated,” taking as truth the claims of one family member over all others and continuing to appoint questionable characters as guardians in lucrative cases without much supervision.

And it’s not just Congress that has taken notice, according to Black. His nonprofit organization keeps track of guardian horror stories from all across the country.

By AAAPG’s count, federal investigators are already actively looking into questionable guardian practices in at least six states.

“We know from families who have contacted us [that the feds] are investigating cases in New York, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Florida, Washington and New Mexico,” where a 28-count indictment on charges of conspiracy, fraud and theft was recently unsealed against Ayudando, a private guardianship company, Black said.

More indictments are expected against others.

In Florida, a federal case brought by the son of a millionaire Texas oilman against two guardianship lawyers ended with a whopping $16.4 million award. No action was taken against the judge who was supposed to be supervising the lawyer’s activities.

“That’s one thing this new bill doesn’t do,” Black said. “It doesn’t address the problem with the judicial system … judges who appoint these guardians in case after case with hardly any follow-up.”

And, as Black notes, the system in states is so entrenched and unaccountable that only action on the federal level can fix it.

Nor does the bill address the need to keep accurate track of how many Americans are held in guardianship or call for a central registry where complaints against unsavory court appointees could be lodged.

“Without a means to keep track of unsuitable guardians, they can be appointed over and over,” Dimond said.

For more information on the cases, visit

Stacy M. Brown

I’ve worked for the Daily News of Los Angeles, the L.A. Times, Gannet and the Times-Tribune and have contributed to the Pocono Record, the New York Post and the New York Times. Television news opportunities have included: NBC, MSNBC, Scarborough Country, the Abrams Report, Today, Good Morning America, NBC Nightly News, Imus in the Morning and Anderson Cooper 360. Radio programs like the Wendy Williams Experience, Tom Joyner Morning Show and the Howard Stern Show have also provided me the chance to share my views.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Washington Informer Newspaper, 3117 Martin Luther King Jr. Ave SE, Washington, DC, 20032, You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

Back to top button

My News Matters to me - Washington Informer Donations

Be a Part of The Washington Informer Legacy

A donation of your choice empowers our journalists to continue the work to better inform, educate and empower you through technology and resources that you use.

Click Here Today to Support Black Press and be a part of the Legacy!

Subscribe today for free and be the first to have news and information delivered directly to your inbox.

Select list(s) to subscribe to

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Washington Informer Newspaper, 3117 Martin Luther King Jr. Ave SE, Washington, DC, 20032, You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

Adblock Detected

Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker